At first glance, these two trench coats from Everlane appear very similar.
(You’d be forgiven if you thought they were the same coat, just in two different colors).
After all, they both have button fastenings, pointed collars, and storm flaps, and both are generously oversized. They both serve the very same purpose: to protect the wearer from the cold and the rain, stylishly.
Looking for more honest style reviews? Check out my index of reviews, sorted by brand
Alas, they are two different coats so there are a few minor differences, and I thought it would be helpful today to share a short comparison of the two in case you were waffling between them. I’ll share a little info about each coat, images showing the fit of each coat, and which one I’m keeping.
If you see something you like, you can shop it here and support this blog at the same time by shopping the affiliate links included in this post. Thank you for your support - it helps keep wayward ad-free and allows me to continue sharing travel and style resources with you. Note: some items in this post were gifted, however, this post is not sponsored.
First, some housekeeping: although these trench coats are shown in different colorways, The Gathered Drape Trench and The Long Mac Coat are both shown in a size small. For reference, my current measurements are 37″-28″-41.5″ and I am 5’4″ tall.
Note for 2024: These coats are no longer available; head here to see Everlane’s current trench offerings
About The Gathered Drape Trench and The Long Mac Coat
The Gathered Drape Trench is made from a 60% Lyocell/40% Cotton blend and comes in three colors and one print (shown here in the Khaki/Black gingham print – no longer available). It features slightly-gathered sleeves, a pointed collar, a high back slit, a removable belt, and is unlined. The fabric feels smooth and slightly silky to the touch and doesn’t tend to hold wrinkles. It has a nice, flowy drape, and when fully fastened, might be easily mistaken for a dress. In the size small, the length from shoulder to hem is 46.5″.
The Long Mac Coat has a 100% Cotton shell with a 100% Recycled Polyester lining and comes in three solid colors (shown here in Toasted Coconut). With raglan sleeves, buttoned cuffs, storm flaps, water-resistant fabric, and a high back slit, it better fits the mold for a traditional mac. It is partially lined, and the fabric feels quite thick and sturdy – and it tends to hold wrinkles. The Long Mac Coat is generously sized and has a shoulder-to-hem length of 46.5″ in the size small. Not noted on the website description is that the left sleeve has an unmissable embroidered letter E.
The measurements for each coat are strikingly similar, however, the fabric greatly impacts how the coats fit. Thanks to the swishier fabric of The Gathered Drape Trench, the coat glides along the body more gently – and of course, the belt brings it in for a snugger fit if desired. The structure of The Long Mac Coat causes it to balloon out a bit more, even if the bottom portion is unlined. As mentioned, I’m wearing a small in both of these jackets; I feel confident that if I sized down one or even two sizes there would still be enough wiggle room on my frame.
Which coat is right for me?
If you’ve visited my blog or Instagram any time in the past month or two, you might know the answer already – but if not: I’m keeping The Gathered Drape Trench. It feels oversized in a good way; in The Long Mac Coat, I feel a bit like a child playing dress up in her father’s coat. The sleeves are far too long and unable to be cuffed easily, and I miss the opportunity for waist definition. I may eventually order The Long Mac Coat in a smaller size, but for now, it isn’t a priority (but I’ll be sure to update this post if anything changes!).
—
If you found this review helpful, please consider shopping through my link. Thank you for your support – it means the world to me!
Looking for more Everlane reviews? You may also like:
- A Review of The ReWool Way-High Drape Pant, The Organic Wide-Leg Pant, The Way-High Sailor Jean, The Italian Leather Chelsea Boot, and The ReNew Catch-All Case
- A review of The Poplin Short-Sleeve Box Shirt, The Cotton-Merino Cami, The ReLeather Tennis Shoe, The Linen Shoestring Jumpsuit, The Organic Cotton Cutaway Tank, The Alpaca Cropped V Cardigan, and The Smock Dress
- A review of The Curvy Way-High Jean, The Japanese GoWeave Slip Dress, The Eyelet Puff Sleeve Top, The Way-High Canvas Short, The A-Line Denim Short, and The Clean Silk Short-Sleeve Square Shirt
- A review of The New Travel-Ready Daytripper Shirtdress, Italian Leather Tourist Heel, Linen Way-High Drape Pant, and Cactus Leather Hobo
- Home Try-On: The Arc Jean
- A review of The Curvy ’90s Cheeky Jean, The Organic Cotton Tissue Tank, The Gathered Drape Trench, and The ReLeather Tennis Shoe
- A Review of The Day Crossover Sandal
Which trench is more your style? And which color speaks to you the most?
